Listed here are all Inductees to the Shrine of the Eternals, by year:
- 1999: DOCK PHILLIP ELLIS, JR., CURTIS CHARLES FLOOD, WILLIAM LOUIS VEECK, JR.
- 2000: MORRIS “MOE” BERG, WILLIAM FRANCIS LEE, PAM POSTEMA
- 2001: JIM BOUTON, SATCHEL PAIGE, JIMMY PIERSALL
- 2002: SHOELESS JOE JACKSON, MARK FIDRYCH, ORESTES “MINNIE” MINOSO
- 2003: JIM ABBOTT, ILA BORDERS, MARVIN MILLER
- 2004: DICK ALLEN, ROBERTO CLEMENTE, WILLIAM “DUMMY” HOY
- 2005: LESTER RODNEY, JACKIE ROBINSON, ROD DEDEAUX
- 2006: JOSH GIBSON, FERNANDO VALENZUELA, and KENICHI ZENIMURA
- 2007: YOGI BERRA, JIM BROSNAN, BILL JAMES
- 2008: EMMETT ASHFORD, BILL BUCKNER, BUCK O’NEIL
- 2009: STEVE DALKOWSKI, JIM EISENREICH, ROGER MARIS
- 2010: ROGER ANGELL, PETE ROSE, CASEY STENGEL
- 2011: TED GIANNOULAS, PETE GRAY, MAURY WILLS
- 2012: JIM “MUDCAT” GRANT, DR. FRANK JOBE, LUIS TIANT
- 2013: EDDIE FEIGNER, MANNY MOTA, LEFTY O’DOUL
- 2014: DIZZY DEAN, RACHEL ROBINSON, DON ZIMMER
- 2015: SY BERGER, GLENN BURKE, STEVE BILKO
- 2016: ARNOLD HANO, BO JACKSON, DON NEWCOMBE
- 2017: CHARLIE BROWN, VIN SCULLY, BOB UECKER
- 2018: NANCY FAUST, TOMMY JOHN, RUSTY STAUB
- 2019: BILLY BEANE, LISA FERNANDEZ, J.R. RICHARD